It’s such as for instance browsing your first Alcoholics Private meeting and you will stating, “I am ____, and I’m an alcoholic
So, and find your own enneagram type of, you first must know that you are substandard in some way or any other. ” If you’re an application step one, you happen to be prideful; while you are a questionnaire dos you are lustful; an such like. Declaring your own enneatype matches announcing which mental condition you dropped sufferer in order to.
Immediately, we see a-sharp evaluate involving the enneagram as well as the MBTI. While it’s correct that Jung was a psychiatrist whose works is actually mainly with substandard patients, their design was however predicated on healthy individuals. Isabel Myers grabbed Jung’s seven “intellectual choice,” split up one to design outside of the remainder of his writing, and you may developed a tool designed to classify this type of healthy personalities. New MBTI is definitely used in this new areas off business, studies, and you will date-to-big date existence as a means out of codifying average mans personalities. There are not any worth judgments; zero type is better than any other type, nor is there a good “sinful” or “diseased” element of people identification variety of.
The entire push of the MBTI (basically away from Keirsey’s temperament principle) is to try to select character products and therefore support telecommunications and expertise between people. It could be–and regularly try–misused in order to identity some body and you may foster bigotry; but that is simply a misuse of the system you to is inspired by ignorance.
Very personally (unless of course I am hopelessly in a condition regarding assertion), new enneagram is largely detrimental
The thrust of the enneagram is to choose important people faults or failings (sins otherwise identification problems). Shown within its most readily useful white, the target would-be to point substandard people in the fresh new recommendations of higher health. But in people situation, the first step are, “There will be something wrong with you.” To shop for towards that is sure to make men feel bad. Additionally, it is bound to result in the enneagram practitioner pick folks since bad as well. To your in addition to front side, that might help some one take on their unique and you can others’ foibles and go after thinking-improvement. But into disadvantage they phone calls awareness of man’s darker qualities; they emphasize this new bad.
Personally, it is far from a highly of use road map
Just as really a Christians end preaching fire and brimstone, extremely enneagram lovers end in public places sharing the fresh dark section of the enneagram. Enneagram books and you can discussion teams are full of laughs and you can friendly stories. Particular enneagram writers feel hopeful given that Dr. Phil. However, one another Dr. Phil together with enneagram generally work with unhealthy thinking and you will decisions. The new logic is apparently, “if you’re not ill, we can’t boost you; therefore earliest you have got to choose one from nine types of diseases.”
This may still be a very important thing if the enneagram had been capable fix somebody–it can not. It’s nothing more than a diagram with accompanying definitions out-of character from the varying amounts of fitness. This may offer helpful yardsticks getting recovering schizophrenics otherwise people who have other identification issues; but even people are nevertheless going to need a lot more help than just so it to essentially get well. The newest enneagram isn’t a data recovery means; it’s merely a drawing–a sort of path chart so you can recuperation.
Complete, I’d say I am pretty darned match. I would personally have to offer my personal creativity and you can suppose some trace out-of disorder, after that look having an easy way to dump one to disease. Meanwhile, I’m likely to become far more notice-engrossed, which is likely to remain myself from emailing and you will insights someone else because they are indeed.
Loaf around an enthusiastic enneagram talk group when it comes to length of time, and you will in the future getting you are in some type of recuperation class. A few people just take pride within their enneatypes, but most admit he’s got problems and therefore are seeking get well of those problems. If in case they actually do get well, several have the enneagram will no longer suffice people of good use purpose. Just after a guy will get vibrant, the newest enneagram becomes unimportant.